I like these two photographs together. One smile is broad enough to draw me in immediately. The other takes a little longer, partly because there’s a substantial rucksack competing for attention.
Once I’ve noticed it, though, the bag becomes much less important.
The smiles are the reason I keep coming back. They have different qualities: an open laugh in the first picture, something more contained in the second. Both make the photographs enjoyable company.
I don’t know what prompted either expression. That doesn’t trouble me much. We’re quite capable of responding to a smile without having the full account, just as we can find ourselves laughing because somebody else has started. Sometimes asking what’s funny only delays matters.
There’s a small pleasure in seeing someone look amused before you’ve had a chance to form any other impression of them. You meet the expression first. Whatever else their day involved, this is the bit the photograph has kept.
I’m glad of that. A serious face can give a street photograph an immediate sense of importance, even when the person was only wondering whether they’d missed their bus. A smile is less mysterious. It offers you something fairly direct, and I don’t think that makes it less interesting.
The first picture has a lovely ease about it. The laughter is prominent, but there’s another smile close by, and people occupy the edges. It feels sociable without my needing to know who knows whom.
In the second, the face has to find its way through a busier view. The smile is smaller, almost tucked into the corner of the scene. I like that it still holds my attention. There’s plenty in front of it, but nothing I’d rather look at.
Neither photograph would gain much from an explanation of exactly how happy anyone was. A smile isn’t a report on the whole day. It’s something that happened during it, which is quite enough.
Perhaps that’s part of their appeal to me. Most days contain a mixture of things, and the pleasant bits don’t always announce themselves as worth remembering. They happen in passing, among conversations, errands and people getting in one another’s way.
Then you look through the photographs and there they are.
These are the sort I’m pleased to find. There may be more complicated pictures alongside them, with more to untangle or explain. I can leave those for a while.
I’ve looked at both faces several times while writing this. The rucksack still hasn’t won.